»FOOD SAFETY OF POULTRY
disease conditions all signi;cantly impact salmonella prevalence on
poultry. These factors cannot be controlled by the industry. Studies have
demonstrated that Salmonellaprevalence varies by season. Moreover,
articles have detailed how higher relative humidity in poultry houses
can increase prevalence. A paper in Poultry Science (Russell, 2003)
detailed how air sacculitis infections increase Campylobacter counts on
broilers. Another popular article with data from more than ;ve million
chickens showed that Salmonella prevalence was signi;cantly higher
on birds with air sacculitis as well. Unfortunately, the FDA decided
to ban the use of the only antibiotic (Enro;oxacin) that is effective for
treating air sacculitis (as shown in a study by the Poultry Diagnostic
Research Center at the University of Georgia).
Human salmonellosis, cases per 100,000
population, Foodnet States, 1996-2008
20
Incidence
15
Trendline
10
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
While Salmonella on chicken is trending down, cases of human salmonellosis are not falling.
to eliminate the last few remaining Salmonella cells on many more
chickens than was required previously. This is a tall order as these cells
are ;rmly attached and require much more effort to eliminate.
USDA-FSIS may be expecting the industry to turn some knobs and
make adjustments in response to the new the regulation that will make
the prevalence go down further. The reality is that the industry will
have a very hard time eliminating those last few salmonella cells that
are making some of the chickens positive for Salmonella.
Sampling methods create confusion
Campylobacter performance standards
A Campylobacter standard puts the poultry industry in a very dif;cult
position. Currently, there is no intervention method that has been demonstrated to be consistently effective for eliminating Campylobacter in
chickens during grow-out. Interventions used to control Salmonella transmission from breeder to baby chick (vaccination and
hatchery intervention) and to prevent colonization of
baby chicks (vaccination and competitive exclusion)
have proven ineffective for Campylobacter. In fact,
the scienti;c community is still divided on whether
Campylobacter is vertically transmitted.
If it is not fully understood how the
Campylobacter organism is colonizing baby
chicks, how can the industry implement effective
interventions? This means the industry is left with
no tools for controlling Campylobacter in broiler
populations, and all interventions must be implemented at the plant level. As with grow-out, no
scienti;c studies exist that demonstrate that one
particular intervention works well for controlling
Campylobacter.
Testing for Campylobacter is costly
The reason why Campylobacter has been